Much as he warns us about a totalitarian regime, a point that should not be missed is his allusion that such a thing could happen in the western democracies too. He is not talking only about the Soviet regime - there is more to it! In as much as he detests the dictatorship and oppression of such regimes he also criticizes the naive acceptance of the same by the common man. It is probably this aspect of the book that should be grasped the most. Animosity towards such ruthless regimes is evident and bound to be. But that is not just what needs to be heeded to. It is the minds of all we people alike. He censures the acceptance of such rules. Given the mindset of the society, as such, we should not be surprised to see ourselves moving towards times when our thinking can be programmed.
There have been heated discussions and debates as to whether 1984 is materializing in today's world as depicted by Orwell. The Orwellian world is an extreme depiction of totalitarian rule. It is criticized for its pessimism. But that was only a way he chose to portray such circumstances. The matter is - we as people are allowing the government bodies to monitor and control us a great deal. What with Acts such as The Patriot Act. Wiki states - Among its many provisions, the act increased the ability of law enforcement agencies to search telephone and email communications and medical, financial, and other records; Agreed that any more 9/11s have to be stalled and that such acts are absolutely necessary to a great extent to protect the Nation. However, beyond that, this Act gives the Government enormous amount of power. This is ability to know every communication of the common man and peek into their social and private lives. Consider the surveillance statistics in
Absolute totalitarianism is beyond just cruel oppression and subjugation. The Orwellian world is about transformation of "gullible" acceptance to a "conscious" one. If Winston was killed that would just have been killing of another soul who protested against the party. But the success of the party lay in the fact that instead of killing a rebel they turned him into a religious follower of the party philosophy. Now that is absolute totalitarianism. Such power so deeply entrenched so as to have control over each individual's consciousness was Orwell's vision. One should not be surprised with his vision given the world that he was part of.
Being a socialist that he was, Marxist influence on him is quite evident. His protagonist Winston detests newspeak - for newspeak obliterates expression of thought. This reminds me of Marx's quote - "'Language is as old as consciousness'. You can't have consciousness without having language, and vice-versa. Therefore, restraining the language restrains consciousness, and freedom of thought." Having gone through the ruthless communist tyranny, what Orwell portended for the future was only an extreme and horrifying vision of the same. In as much as he hated the Soviet Regime his attempt was to caution people about the extremities of such a rule and more so in putting up with one!
Friday, June 22, 2007
1984
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Great blog.. got me thinking on the subject of a totalitarian society..I havnt read 1984 but two movies that I have seen really influenced my thinking on the subject - "Brazil"- this was definately based on 1984 and the ending was brilliant adn very similar to what you say where in the system breaks the protoganist who is trying to rebel- that is the scariest part...
the other movie was a movie made by Akira Kurasawa- "Ikuru"- now this was a contemprary veiw - a neorelistic movie-- the movie was taken in the early fifties but I could identify with what kurasawa tries to potray even after all these years in how our society is degrading to fit a system...
Hi ,
I was reading ur blog posts and found some of them to be very good.. u write well.. Why don't you popularize it more.. ur posts on ur blog ‘Raw renditions’ took my particular attention as some of them are interesting topics of mine too;
BTW I help out some ex-IIMA guys who with another batch mate run www.rambhai.com where you can post links to your most loved blog-posts. Rambhai was the chaiwala at IIMA and it is a site where users can themselves share links to blog posts etc and other can find and vote on them. The best make it to the homepage!
This way you can reach out to rambhai readers some of whom could become your ardent fans.. who knows.. :)
Cheers,
Post a Comment